The State of PIA - November 2026
· Sean Creeley
I wanted to take a moment to discuss the current state of PIA, where we have been, and what we have planned for next year.
For context, we acquired Waters Aero-Marine in late October 2023. We view the business as seasonal, with the high season running from June 15th to September 15th each year, and the rest of the year spent supporting full-time residents and contractors and preparing for the next high season. As we’ve closed out our third high season, it’s a good time to stop and reflect.
The first season was about learning; we lowered the pricing and gained insight into how the place operated. The second season was about building blocks; we retired the paper dispatch calendar, bought the Robin R and a float in Matinicus Harbor, and rebuilt the maintenance department. The third season was about operational excellence: taking all the pieces we have assembled and deploying them in service of the customer. I wouldn’t say we hit excellence; I would say we crushed it compared to last season. Let’s begin.
Freight
The Ground people had a year. Honestly, it looked pretty bleak in March when USPS hadn’t paid us and Amazon packages were moving from UPS, where we had a contract, to USPS, where we get paid by the trip, and FedEx, where we didn’t have a contract. Tumbleweeds were common on the loading dock, but Ground didn’t stay slow for long.
In April, Bo appeared on all three of Maine’s nightly news programs after we staged a mini strike, refusing to deliver the mail to the islands after USPS failed to pay down its then-$380k balance. We were overwhelmed by the support from the residents of the islands, Maine in general, and our elected officials. We have a fun official letter from the Maine delegation to the US Postmaster about a little flying service supporting the islands that is pretty cool. USPS’s balance over the last year is now in the double digits as we work through the remaining smaller points.
In June, after FedEx’s subcontractor to North Haven and Vinalhaven was overloaded, we stepped in to help deliver hundreds of packages to the islands. At peak, we loaded a van onto the ferry, then took whatever didn’t fit to the Robin R; anything left after that went by plane. Instead of one person per island, we had two. The intern, Tom, would end up driving his hatchback around Vinalhaven when things got hectic.
To add to the chaos, we moved from paper to scanners for tracking all our packages. These little devices read FedEx/UPS barcodes and recreate everything you expect from modern tracking in a smaller footprint. We know where every package is at all times; before, Bo would sift through literal boxes of paper to see if we had a package, but there was no way to know if and when it was delivered. In modern freight, Proof of Delivery is foundational, which is why we take pictures of your porch. Scanning adds overhead for delivery drivers, but saves you and the back office hours of work each week. Next time you want to know if we have a package, try our Freight tracker.
Scanners also give us data. During June, July, and August, we delivered 22,617 packages: 7,974 to Vinalhaven, 7,786 to North Haven, 5,636 to Islesboro, and 1,221 to Matinicus. July was the peak month with 8,584, and July 7th was the peak day with 442.
As of November 3rd, our temporary agreement with FedEx has turned permanent, and we will be their subcontractor on North Haven, Vinalhaven, and Matinicus for at least another year. We have invested in infrastructure to support deliveries going forward. If you haven’t seen the toasters yet, we have three. Chevy built a bunch of electric delivery trucks called BrightDrops that no one wanted, discontinued the vehicle, and cut their price in half.
[TK] Toasters
Who’s dumb enough to buy an untested, discontinued electric vehicle that only gets 200 miles on a charge? We are. The economics make sense: cheaper than a five-year-old Ford Transit, with lower operating costs (fuel and maintenance), they have already made a dent in auto expenses. I get this holds true until a toaster dies in the cold on an island, though we did buy a long extension cord. Liam, the mechanic, refuses to even make eye contact with them.
Big props to Bo, Wink, Ant, Cindy, Rob, Jadon, Holly, Walter, Preston, Laura, Kelly, and Justin for making the invisible part of PIA just work.
Boat
PIA more than doubled our usage of the Robin R this year. We are not a boat company, but some days, it feels like it. We continue to find success in using the boat as a backup vehicle to the islands. Whether that's bringing contractors to the islands when they are fogged in the morning, freight runs, or general transportation. People are more comfortable booking early, knowing we will get them on the island. Where we expanded was excursions. We did way more trips to Seal Island and Matinicus Rock this year than last. Puffins and seals are apparently a decent business.
George Tarkleson has rejoined the Robin R to handle the boat itself (it got a new GPS) and training captains and deckhands. I find it interesting to operate a boat in a place where a good portion of the residents make a living operating a boat. You all just assume the pilots know what they are doing, but half the people that ride with us know the waterways better than we do. I appreciate the commentary and that everyone is down for a good ribbing, and you're also the first ones to find us gas when we run out on an island.
The Matinicus wharf needs some attention, and we know it. We had a marine engineering firm come out this fall to take a look at it. Long term, we’ll be redecking the whole thing; short term, we'll shore up the float and the ramp. It’s been beneficial at low tide and for making sure no one has to climb a ladder, but it has its own hazards, like falling through a rotten board. Greta has taken on this lovely mission.
I think we have found our short-term fit for the boat. Excess freight and weather. We’ll run scheduled trips to Matinicus again next year and expand our excursion offerings, but we won’t add scheduled service to the other islands. You can’t compete with a publicly subsidized ferry system.
Big thanks to our captains, George, Chris, and Stan, and as of a few weeks ago, dispatcher Val has joined the roster. Honorable mention to first mate-turned-dispatcher Greta, who also doubles as our scuba diver to cut rope off the prop shaft.
Emergency Services
We started counting medevacs separately in May of this year, and since then we’ve done 61. 56 for Vinalhaven and 5 for North Haven. Unsurprisingly, the peak was August with 15, so every other day we were pulling someone off an island for a medical emergency. There is a super-secret red phone in the office that only the islands' EMTs have the number for, which has drastically increased their ability to reach us and our ability to dispatch planes faster. We appreciate the EMTs on both islands for working so closely with us. In the same vein, we had one trip for the sheriff's department and another for the coroner, though unrelated.
Planes
Alright, you may not believe me, but online booking and dynamic pricing are working. We’ve increased revenue per trip by 14% and dropped the average ticket by 7%. Basically, PIA is making more money while lowering ticket prices. How, you ask? Great question. It’s a combination of more efficient routing and encouraging users to make smarter decisions about when they fly. People booking online have the same information as dispatchers. The majority of our flights are still booked through dispatch. It’s nearly impossible to change user behavior and the convenience of making a phone call, but 100% of flights booked between 7pm and 6am are online.
Dispatch has fundamentally changed as well. If you’ve called lately and talked to Susan, she’s sitting comfortably at her house in South Carolina. Her job is the first line of defense, quoting flights, booking flights, changing flights, and tracking freight. None of which require her to be in Rockland. If Susan is on with another caller or it’s the weekend, the call rolls over to the dispatcher at the desk. By bifurcating the job, the desk can focus on pilot safety and customers in the building without the phone ringing constantly. This is still a work in progress, but I appreciate Susan, Val, and Greta being down for this experiment.
The pilots are still piloting. In the high season, they flew 1,604 trips for 4,012 passengers and 90 scenic flights for 239 passengers. The pilots also flew farther. Miles flown past Portland doubled to 9,633 nm this year to places like Rome, NY, Boston Logan, and Burlington, VT. We lost Steve C to the majors right before the 4th of July, which was less than ideal. Stan, Steve T, Olivia, Bennett, and Hamish all stepped up, taking more days to get everyone where they needed to go. The plan is to run four airplanes next summer. We actually sold out a few days this summer, and pilots, it turns out, don’t love flying eight hours a day. You’ll see some new faces in the cockpit come the new year.
We are also delivering more groceries this year. I don’t have great historical numbers on this one, but in the last month and a half, the pilots have delivered 128 banana boxes. We expanded scheduled pickups, if you haven’t heard, so you can get your groceries or household needs by plane!
Maintenance
Here’s a sentence I never thought I’d write. We did not miss a revenue flight due to maintenance over the summer. Sure, we had to move a few around, but this is relatively unheard of within the current iteration of PIA. Good air services have good maintenance departments. They keep pilots and passengers safe and planes flying. Lonny, Liam, and Holden, who is now a newly minted A&P, have crushed it over the summer.
Lonny’s only ask is for everyone to be nicer to the flap rollers.
Fleet
Waters Aero-Marine right now owns 8 1/2 planes. We are still working on getting rid of the two 207s, and you should buy them. Two are up north at Katahdin Air; one is the trainer; and the half is the plane we got out of a barn in Minnesota that Lonny is putting back together. By the summer, we hope to be at 9 planes: two 206s on floats at Katahdin, five 206s at PIA, and two trainers. Running a flight school on a single 172 isn’t working. We had the choice to go after a twin platform or invest in the flight school; we are going to give the flight school a little love. 2028 will be the year of the twin.
Business
We are still alive. We are still investing every dollar we earn back into the company and its people. We get one large purchase a year; last year it was the 206, this year the toasters took our free cash. I remind Ground every day that they are the golden children this year.
We’ve hired a business manager to help keep us making good decisions. Maya Sousa joined us in early November. If the name sounds familiar, she owned the Owls Head General Store before joining us. If you can keep a restaurant afloat in Owls Head, an air service should be simple. A big thank you to Chelsea and Alane, who helmed the finance department over the last year.
Sortie
The team at Sortie continues to build software, most of which you don’t see but still benefit from, helping PIA run a significantly smoother operation. Katahdin Air is the second airline to join Sortie, but they joined late in the season. We’ll have some fun data for them next year. We have a lot more to build, but soon you’ll see other air services adopt the software we developed here for PIA. Dan, Pedro, Collin, Charlie, Eva, and Lakshmi, thank you for what you do.
Closing
Every time Bo panics about something, I remind him that it’s a five-year plan. It’s no secret that PIA was failing when we took over, and it didn’t get better at first; it got worse. It took significant investment in people and equipment, but this year is the first year we've grown overall revenue, not a ton, but enough. Enough to show signs of turning the corner. Enough to show that it’s working. Enough to show our fragile network is growing stronger. I appreciate the whole bay’s patience as we got our footing. We are surviving on your support and continued trust.
Lastly, the people who work at PIA are impressive. They believe in the mission and love the islands and their inhabitants. They show up every day in the service of the residents of Penobscot Bay. In the words of the company's namesake, flying is a choice; we want you to make that choice.